Do We Really Need a Third Fight Between Serrano and Taylor or Is It Time for a Fresh Female Main Event?
- Eric J Herrholz
- Jun 12
- 4 min read
The world of boxing has captivated fans for generations, and the women’s division has recently experienced a surge in popularity. Stars like Amanda Serrano and Katie Taylor are at the forefront of this movement, with their intense rivalry fueling excitement among supporters. After two thrilling bouts, many are now asking: Is a third fight necessary, or should we turn our attention to new contenders in women's boxing?
The Electrifying History Between Serrano and Taylor
Amanda Serrano and Katie Taylor first faced off in 2021, delivering a fight that left viewers in awe. The bout was a testament to their power and skill, leading Taylor to a split-decision victory that few could forget. Their rematch in 2022 showcased even higher levels of intensity, and it drew an impressive viewership, becoming one of the most discussed fights of the year. Reports suggest that the rematch alone attracted over 800,000 viewers on major broadcast platforms.
However, as thrilling as these encounters have been, a growing concern is surfacing within the boxing community. Common wisdom suggests that trilogies can become repetitive, potentially hindering the overall growth of women’s boxing. The pressing question now is whether Serrano and Taylor should continue their rivalry or explore new opportunities in the sport.
Are Trilogies Always Worth It?
Trilogies hold a unique charm. They bring heightened anticipation and a narrative arc that can be captivating. Iconic trilogies like Ali vs. Frazier drew millions in attendance and changed the landscape of boxing. Yet, not every rivalry is destined for three fights.
Consider this: Trilogies should be conducted when both fighters can bring something new to the table. In recent years, women's boxing has experienced a renaissance, with an influx of rising stars eager to make their mark. For example, fighters like Claressa Shields, a two-time Olympic gold medalist, and Jessica McCaskill, a relentless competitor, have made strong cases for their own showcase bouts.
Focusing exclusively on Serrano and Taylor might prevent these new talents from shining. Diversifying matchups can lead to equally excitement and even higher ratings.
The Case for New Faces
While Serrano and Taylor are icons of the sport, other emerging fighters deserve attention. Claressa Shields, with her powerful punches and magnetic personality, has garnered substantial acclaim, becoming a household name. Additionally, Jessica McCaskill's fighting style, known for its relentless pressure, could create electrifying matchups and intrigue among fans.
Promoting new rivalries is crucial for the health of women's boxing. Fresh faces and unseen matchups can create buzz that has the potential to capture a broader audience. For instance, when Shields and McCaskill faced off in the 2022 championship, the bout drew more than 500,000 viewers, illustrating substantial public interest in new narratives.
The Impact on Women’s Boxing
Focusing solely on the Serrano-Taylor saga risks overshadowing the strides that women’s boxing has made in recent years. The dynamic landscape has seen increased representation, with more female fighters being recognized and celebrated for their talents. In 2022 alone, the number of female fighters licensed by various boxing commissions grew by 20%. This movement can inspire young women to pursue boxing, expand the sport's audience, and forge deeper rivalries that fans will follow.
Headlining events with new competitors would contribute to long-term growth in women’s boxing. By offering diverse fight cards featuring multiple matchups, promoters can foster interest and excitement, ensuring that the sport continues to thrive.
The Role of MVP (Most Valuable Promotions)
Promoters are key players in shaping the future of boxing. Most Valuable Promotions has been instrumental in raising the profile of female athletes, yet they have a responsibility to promote a variety of events. Instead of solely banking on a longstanding rivalry, MVP should invest in diverse matchups that resonate with fans.
For example, hosting a card featuring multiple female fighters, and incorporating some undercard bouts can create an electrifying atmosphere. This strategy can not only increase interest but also provide a stage for upcoming talent, promoting the next generation of fighters.
Fans’ Perspectives Matter
Fans are the lifeblood of any sport, and their opinions are invaluable in shaping the direction of matchmaking. While there remains undeniable skill from Serrano and Taylor, audiences may tire of repetitive matchups.
Imagine the excitement a new champion could generate. Fans relish the unpredictability of watching fresh fighters rise to challenge established stars. Moreover, a lineup that includes rising stars can enhance the event, making it more appealing to a broader audience.
What's Next for Serrano and Taylor?
What paths lie ahead for Serrano and Taylor? If both fighters aim to create a legacy that extends beyond their rivalry, they should venture into new challenges. This could mean seeking title shots against other champions or supporting emerging fighters in their journeys. Both options allow them to contribute to the sport's evolution while carving out their legacies.
Time for a Change in Direction
As we reflect on Amanda Serrano and Katie Taylor's remarkable contributions to boxing, it's essential to recognize that women's boxing is expanding. There is no doubt that their fights have thrilled audiences, but it’s vital to shift our focus toward fostering fresh rivalries.
While trilogies can be nostalgic, they should not obscure the potential for new matchups to invigorate the sport. Fans, promoters, and fighters collectively play a crucial role in driving this evolution. Let us embrace the potential of fresh beginnings, cultivating new rivalries that push women's boxing to new heights.
